Notices & responses
No reply to a notice: what happens next?
Silence is not consent, but it does not leave every project permanently stuck.
For party structure and qualifying excavation notices, no written consent within 14 days leads to a deemed dispute. Surveyor appointment is a separate step.
Identify which notice was served
Different notices have different consequences. The deemed-dispute rules apply to party structure notices and the relevant excavation notices. Lack of written consent to a new wall astride the boundary instead restricts the wall position under section 1. First check the notice type, its validity and service record before deciding what the silence means.
Do not appoint someone on day fifteen by default
Section 10(4) deals with a party who refuses to appoint a surveyor or neglects to do so for ten days after the other party serves a request. The statutory request is distinct from the original notice and its 14-day response period. Have the correct request, service and appointment route checked before relying on an appointment made for someone else.
An appointment for the neighbour is not an agreed appointment
When the statutory conditions permit an appointment on the non-cooperating owner’s behalf, that is a separate surveyor appointment. It does not turn the building owner’s surveyor into an Agreed Surveyor. The appointed professionals still have to carry out their duties impartially and address the relevant dispute within the Act.
Keep contact calm and documented
Send clear contact details and offer the neighbour a straightforward way to respond. Check whether a letter has gone to an outdated address or an owner is away. Record the formal steps separately from informal reminders. If there is continuing uncertainty, ask the surveyor to identify the next valid action rather than repeatedly sending notices with conflicting dates.
General guidance for England and Wales, rather than a determination of an individual case. Legal points reviewed on 27 October 2026.
Sources: Act section 1, Act section 5, Act section 6, Act section 10; Government explanatory booklet. Government material is available under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Part of the Murus network 