MurusPart of the Murus network England & Wales · Email-only service

Surveyors & Awards

One Agreed Surveyor or separate surveyors?

Both routes can resolve a party wall dispute, but the appointment needs to fit the circumstances.

Value Party Wall · Reviewed 27 October 2026 · England & Wales

The key point

An Agreed Surveyor is jointly appointed by both owners. With separate appointments, the two surveyors select a third surveyor.

Understand the single-surveyor route

Both parties can concur in appointing one Agreed Surveyor to determine the dispute. That agreement must be in writing. The surveyor considers the relevant rights of both owners; they are not the building owner’s advocate simply because that owner is paying. A neighbour should have enough information about the proposed appointment to make an informed choice.

Understand separate appointments

Each owner can appoint a surveyor. Those surveyors select a third surveyor under the Act, normally to be called upon if necessary. Separate appointments can be useful where the owners prefer independent points of contact or the matters require fuller discussion. There is no automatic requirement for the third surveyor to become involved in every routine decision.

Discuss fees without assuming the outcome

One appointment can avoid duplication, but the correct arrangement depends on the dispute and the owners’ agreement. Reasonable statutory costs are determined under the Act. Neither route justifies charging for unnecessary work, and a cheaper headline quotation should not be the only reason for accepting an appointment whose scope is unclear.

Make the choice before signing

Ask who will communicate decisions, what information is needed and how an unresolved issue would be addressed. A valid section 10 appointment cannot simply be revoked by an owner later because they prefer another approach. If you are unsure about the route, get the explanation before making the statutory appointment rather than treating it as a provisional booking.

General guidance for England and Wales, rather than a determination of an individual case. Legal points reviewed on 27 October 2026.

Sources: Act section 10, Act section 20; Government explanatory booklet. Government material is available under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

← Browse all 30 guides